The Pope Is Catholic After All

Published February 13, 2020

The Wall Street Journal

Catholics, take heart. Pope Francis ’ apostolic exhortation on the Amazon Synod, released Wednesday, is no truth-and-tradition-shredding document. On point after point, the Holy Father reiterates the longstanding teaching of the Catholic Church—whether on the role of the priest, the centrality of women to the church’s mission, or the continued importance of priestly celibacy.

Over the past few months the pope’s critics within the church have worried that the Vatican would chip away or discard Catholicism’s moral theology. The rhetoric sometimes made it sound as if the sky were falling, taking the Barque of St. Peter with it. Such fear is unbecoming of all who place their trust in God and believe his promise that the “gates of hell shall not prevail” against the church.

These concerns came from genuine care. At the conclusion of the Amazon Synod in October, the bishops voted to recommend the ordination of married men as priests in certain South American regions, despite millennia-old Catholic teaching and discipline to the contrary. They also recommended further discussion on allowing local women to be deacons. Under Catholic doctrine, deacons receive Holy Orders, as do bishops and priests. This sacrament always has been reserved to men. The fear was that abandoning such teachings in the Amazon was the first step toward change across the entire church.

Click here to read the rest of this piece at the Wall Street Journal‘s website.

Mr. Busch is founder of the Napa Institute, a Catholic lay organization. Ms. Hasson, a board member of the Institute, is a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center.

Most Read

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up to receive EPPC's biweekly e-newsletter of selected publications, news, and events.


Your support impacts the debate on critical issues of public policy.

Donate today

More in Catholic Womens Forum

Related Publications

EPPC Scholars Meet with Federal Officials to Discuss Concerns over Proposed Transgender Treatment Mandate for Veterans

Mary Rice Hasson

EPPC Kate O’Beirne Senior Fellow Mary Rice Hasson and Fellow Rachel N. Morrison met with federal government officials to discuss concerns over a proposal by the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (VA) to remove the current exclusion for “gender alterations” from its medical benefits package. The scholars objected to the VA’s characterization that such care is “medically necessary” and that it is “consistent with medical industry standards.”



The Pope and the Patriarch of Moscow

George Weigel

A meeting between the current Bishop of Rome and the current Patriarch of Moscow would not have been a meeting of two religious leaders. It would have been a meeting between a religious leader and an instrument of Russian state power.


Syndicated Column / April 27, 2022

Back to the Future?

Stephen P. White

That there is opposition to Pope Francis in the Church is as obvious, even as it is difficult to define just what constitutes opposition


The Catholic Thing / April 7, 2022

EPPC Scholars Meet with Federal Officials to Discuss Concerns Over Upcoming Title IX Rule

Rachel N. Morrison

EPPC fellows Rachel N. Morrison and Mary Hasson met with federal government officials to discuss concerns over an upcoming proposed rule by the Department of Education that would impact Title IX regulations. EPPC scholars shared eight major points of concern, including the harms of redefining “sex discrimination” to include “gender identity.”