‘Lex orandi, lex civitandi’


Published June 15, 2025

The Catholic Thing

Let’s do a little thought experiment. Do you think you could guess my political affiliation based on what music I listen to? Does my preference for, say, Jimmy Buffet, yacht rock, and country music from the late 1990s tip my political hand at all? These hypothetical musical preferences might tell you something about me (I have eclectic tastes, I’m probably part of Gen X, etc.), but would they tell you very much about how I vote? Probably not.

One person is a tiny sample size and, as the saying goes, there’s no accounting for taste. What if I asked you about a larger group?

What if there were 1,000 people or 10,000 people who all liked Jimmy Buffet, yacht rock, and country music from the late 1990s? Now, do you think you could, with reasonable accuracy, guess the general political leanings of that group based simply on their shared taste in music? Has the larger sample size made that guess about political preferences easier, more difficult, or about the same?

Now, what if I told you (again, hypothetically) that I attend Mass every Sunday and that my three all-time favorite hymns to sing are, in no particular order, “On Eagle’s Wings,” “City of God,” and “Be Not Afraid”? I especially like it when these songs are accompanied by an acoustic guitar.

Do you think you could venture a guess about my politics now?

I bet you do. At the very least, most of you have a hunch. Prudence might convince you to withhold that judgment. You might make some objection about “inductive fallacies” or “correlation not implying causation.” You know you shouldn’t judge, but that doesn’t mean you’re not also pretty confident that you could judge. The answer is already there in the back of your head. Even if you’re withholding it, you know what judgment you’re withholding.

Let’s leave that (admittedly loaded) hypothetical for a moment and turn to the reality of the Church and the country in which we live. We hear a lot about political polarization these days, for obvious reasons. We also hear a lot about the ways in which political polarization has seeped into the Church.

While political polarization may exacerbate our ecclesial divisions, our most significant ecclesial divisions – e.g., about liturgy or sexual morality or the proper interpretation of Vatican II – long predate the current moment of political polarization. Moreover, as I’ve written before, it’s hard to see American political polarization as the prime driver of our ecclesial divisions when so much of the Church outside the United States, and thus well removed from our domestic polarization, is dealing with very similar divisions.

The Last Supper by Jacopo Tintoretto, c. 1593 [Church of San Giorgio Maggiore, Venice]

Political polarization is at least as much a symptom of our ecclesial divisions as it is a cause. And I’m not the first to observe that many of our political divisions are underwritten by much deeper disagreements about the nature and ends of human life.

Those anthropological questions are, to the Christian mind, inherently theological questions. So we shouldn’t be surprised to discover that the way we pray (or even what we like to sing) somehow shows up in the way we view our political life and the responsibilities of citizenship. Lex orandi, lex credendi, lex vivendi. The way we pray shapes the way we believe, which in turn shapes the way we live. To which we might add, lex civitandi – the way we pray eventually shapes the way we exercise our citizenship.

Now, of course, we can’t really tell much about people’s political beliefs based solely on what sort of liturgical music they prefer. No doubt, there are progressives out there who love to chant the Regina Coeli and conservatives who long to “Sing a New Church” into being.

Nor am I suggesting that liturgical renewal ought to be seen as a means to some political end, even a worthy political end. Instrumentalizing the worship of God is a wicked and disordered thing to do. But it is the case that right worship cannot but be a boon to the life of any community that so worships.

In a recent homily marking the Jubilee of the Holy See, Pope Leo XIV observed that, “All the fruitfulness of the Church and of the Holy See depends on the Cross of Christ.” He continued,

In fact, the fruitfulness of Mary and of the Church are inextricably linked to their holiness, which is their conformity to Christ. The Holy See is holy as the Church is holy, in her original core, in the very fabric of her being. The Apostolic See thus preserves the holiness of its roots while being preserved by them. But it is no less true that it also lives in the holiness of each of its members. Therefore, the best way to serve the Holy See is to strive for holiness, each according to his or her particular state of life and the work entrusted to him or her.

What is true for those who work for the Holy See, and who would see its mission succeed, is also true for those of us who would see our political life healed and our nation flourish. The best way to serve our country is to strive for holiness, each according to his or her particular state of life. The fruitfulness of our labors in that dimension of our lives, as in all dimensions of our lives, depends on our conformity to Christ.

In this context, we can see how the Church plays a truly irreplaceable role in the life and health of our nation. It is common to hear it said that politics is downstream from culture. Which is true, so long as one allows that culture is also, at times, very much downstream from politics. The Church is different. She is in the midst of both, but ultimately belongs to neither. She transcends them. And she teaches us how, through conformity to Christ and striving for holiness, we might be granted the grace to do the same.


Stephen P. White is a fellow in the Catholic Studies Program at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. Mr. White’s work focuses on the application of Catholic social teaching to a broad spectrum of contemporary political and cultural issues. He is the author of Red, White, Blue, and Catholic (Liguori Publications, 2016).

Most Read

EPPC BRIEFLY
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up to receive EPPC's biweekly e-newsletter of selected publications, news, and events.

SEARCH

Your support impacts the debate on critical issues of public policy.

Donate today

More in Catholic Studies