A Compendium on the Kavanaugh Nomination


A Compendium on the Kavanaugh Nomination

I am compiling this ongoing compendium of materials on the Kavanaugh nomination in order to give the interested reader guided access to selected items that I consider worth reading. I have not attempted to be exhaustive, nor does my inclusion of an item mean that I necessarily agree with it. — Ed Whelan 


Role of a judge 

  • Judge Kavanaugh delivered a speech at the Catholic University of America titled “Judge as Umpire: Ten Principles.” A summary of that speech is available here 
  • Judge Kavanaugh spoke on the judge’s role in preserving the separation of powers between the three branches [Video Only]. 
  • Judge Kavanaugh reflected on Justice Antonin Scalia.  
  • Judge Kavanaugh reflected on Chief Justice William Rehnquist. 
  • Judge Kavanaugh participated in a panel on the role that history should play in judicial interpretation at George Washington. 
  • Judge Kavanaugh spoke on statutory interpretation and the Chevron doctrine at the Heritage Foundation 
  • Judge Kavanaugh participated in a panel on federal courts at Harvard 
  • Judge Kavanaugh spoke on the enduring significance of the text of the Constitution at Notre Dame 

Separation of powers 

  • Judge Kavanaugh spoke on the judge’s role in preserving the separation of powers among the three branches at AEI [Video Only]. 
  • Christopher Walker reviews Judge Kavanaugh on administrative law and the separation of powers 
  • Judge Kavanaugh discussed separation of powers controversies during the George W. Bush and Barack Obama presidencies at Marquette [Video Only]. 
  • Judge Kavanaugh proposed some ideas to improve the health of America’s political institutions. 
  • Carrie Severino on two of Judge Kavanaugh’s major separation-of-powers opinions 
  • Peter Wallison in WSJ on how Judge Kavanaugh may restore separation of powers

 

 Federalism 

  • Elaine Povich and Alayna Alvarez assess Judge Kavanaugh’s rulings to predict his views on federalism and state rights. 

 

 Congressional powers 

  • Judge Kavanaugh reviewed Judge Barron’s book on legislative-executive debates in wartime. 

 

 Presidential powers  

  • Carrie Severino presents Judge Kavanaugh’s views on U.S. v. Nixon. 
  • Ben Wittes explains how Judge Kavanaugh’s rulings won’t affect the Mueller investigations. 
  • Ed Whelan debunks Senate Democrats’ distortions about Judge Kavanaugh’s view of subpoenas and special investigations  
  • Judge Kavanaugh reviewed Judge Barron’s book on legislative-executive debates in wartime. 
  • Harvard law professor Noah Feldman rejects Senate Democrats’ claims about Judge Kavanaugh’s supposed position on indicting a president 

 

 Religious Liberty  

  • Hiram Sasser praises Judge Kavanaugh’s record on religious liberty cases and his prior pro bono work on behalf of religious organizations.  
  • Ed Whelan looks into Judge Kavanaugh’s religious-liberty jurisprudence. 
  • Kelly Shackelford, the CEO of First Liberty Institute, calls Judge Kavanaugh a strict adherent to the Constitution and a defender of religious liberties  

 

 Free Speech  

  • Ken White reviews Judge Kavanaugh’s free speech decisions on the DC Circuit.  
  • Institute for Free Speech posts a four-part series exploring Judge Kavanaugh’s jurisprudence in the sphere.  
  • Brian Miller notes how Judge Kavanaugh is impartial in his support of free speech. 

 

 Second Amendment  

  • SCOTUSblog’s assessment of Judge Kavanaugh’s record on the Second Amendment 
  • Ed Whelan on Judge Kavanaugh’s record on the Second Amendment  

 

 Fourth Amendment 

  • Orin Kerr provides tentative analysis of Judge Kavanaugh’s views of the Fourth Amendment 
  • Ed Whelan corrects mischaracterizations of two of Judge Kavanaugh’s Fourth Amendment decisions 

 

 Administrative law 

  • Eugene Scalia on why Judge Kavanaugh should appeal to to both Democrats and Republicans when it comes to administrative law. 
  • Jonathan Adler writes in NYT that Judge Kavanaugh will keep administrative agencies within the limits of law and delegated authority. Adler also writes a more substantive post for Reason.  
  • Jeff Pojanowski explicates Judge Kavanaugh’s interpretation of the major questions doctrine  
  • Christopher Walker interprets Judge Kavanaugh’s stance towards independent agencies  
  • Christopher Walker reviewed Judge Kavanaugh on administrative law and the separation of powers 
  • Jonathan Wood proclaims that Judge Kavanaugh may help reverse Chevron  
  • Aaron Nielsen compiled a list of all of Judge Kavanaugh’s concurrences and dissents at Notice & Comment blog  
  • Michael McConnell explains how Judge Kavanaugh’s confirmation may curtail Chevron’s footprint.

 

 Campaign finance  

 

 Environmental law 

  • Jonathan Adler in NRO pointing out selective reporting on Judge Kavanaugh’s environmental record 

 

 Immigration 

  • Ed Whelan briefly surveys Judge Kavanaugh’s record in immigration cases 

 

 Voting rights  

  • Hans von Spakovsky explains that Judge Kavanaugh holds a mainstream position on voting rights 

 

 Other Legal Areas 

  • Dan McLaughlin at NRO on Judge Kavanaugh on expert testimony on “battered woman syndrome  
  • Ed Whelan corrects misconceptions about Judge Kavanaugh’s vote in a routine case involving Trump Casino 

 

 The Confirmation Process 

  • Ed Whelan on Senator Schumer’s demand for documents from Judge Kavanaugh’s time in the White House Counsel’s Office 
  • Ed Whelan responds to John Podesta and Todd Stern on Senator Schumer’s demand for documents from Judge Kavanaugh’s time in the White House Counsel’s Office 
  • More from Ed Whelan on Senator Schumer’s demand for documents from Judge Kavanaugh’s time in the White House Counsel’s Office 
  • Thomas Jipping responds to Senator Durbin’s innuendos regarding Judge Kavanaugh’s D.C. Circuit confirmation hearings 
  • Carrie Severino also outlines how Democrats are trotting out baseless attacks alleging that Judge Kavanaugh helped shape the Bush administration’s interrogation policies.
  • David French discredits a flawed New York Times piece that distorts Judge Kavanauagh’s role in the failed nomination of District Judge Charles Pickering to the Fifth Circuit.

 

 Endorsements from Legal Figures

  • Yale law professor Akhil Amar on a liberal’s case for Judge Kavanaugh 
  • Former Justice Kennedy clerks in support of Judge Kavanaugh  
  • Harvard law professor Jack Goldsmith in support of Judge Kavanaugh 
  • The Cato Institute’s Ilya Shapiro on the libertarian case for Judge Kavanaugh’s confirmation 
  • Georgetown law professor Randy Barnett concurs with Ilya Shapiro’s libertarian case for Judge Kavanaugh 
  • 41 leading Supreme Court advocates signed a letter voicing their support for Judge Kavanaugh’s nomination, citing his many years on the DC Circuit and “character, temperament, and intellect.”

Most Read

EPPC BRIEFLY
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up to receive EPPC's biweekly e-newsletter of selected publications, news, and events.

Upcoming Event |

The Two-Parent Privilege?: A Discussion on Marriage, Economic Opportunity

SEARCH

Your support impacts the debate on critical issues of public policy.

Donate today